With the greatest respect to Frank, I don't think his latest ideas on chat are the way forward. PW won't every be a mass-market game, but it could have a solid and loyal userbase in the hundreds at least.
IMO, PW needs to do two things:
1. Keep the depth which appeals to existing long-term players; and
2. Address the issues which are putting off/driving away new players.
Under (1) I would include, for example, retaining the 7 day cycle, and the depth of development/production;
The second set of issues (for me at least) which would affect new players in their early weeks include:
- the staff system: far too many potential staff, most of whom are hopeless, with no real way of finding out who is any good (or has potential) other than the crazy scouting system (scouting your own staff to find their ability?!);
- reliability of poor-quality (ie beginner) parts... it's no fun for new players to trail round at Save the Car/70% just to try and get to the finish, and even then suffer random failures; and
- lack of opposition. The proposed AI teams to fill divisions is a brilliant idea, and would make races interesting for new players in div 3. Is it also worth investigating reducing the number of 3rd divisions to 8, so that there are more human opponents?
Looking at other online games, there doesn't seem to be a big market for in-depth, detailed games which reward patience and thinking. On the other hand, PW can't compete with existing "quick fix" racing games which have a head start on graphics, users etc.
I really hope Frank keeps the "soul" of PW, makes it more accessible for new players, and tweaks some of the bugs/balancing issues (e.g. difficulty of overtaking in races, stalling youth races) so that it will keep a loyal (and hopefully growing) userbase.